Return to Duty Process: A Complete Guide for Employers and Employees

When an employee fails a drug or alcohol test, the return-to-duty process ensures they can safely and legally return to safety-sensitive work duties. Whether you’re a DOT-regulated employer, an owner-operator, or a human resource manager, understanding this structured process is vital for staying compliant with federal and state regulations.

Workplace Screening Intelligence (WSI) provides complete support from SAP evaluations to FMCSA Clearinghouse reporting.

What Happens After Failing a Drug Test?

If an employee fails a DOT or non-DOT drug test, the return-to-duty process begins immediately:

1. Immediate Removal from all safety-sensitive functions.
2. Evaluation by a Substance Abuse Professional (SAP).
3. Completion of the SAP’s recommended education or treatment plan.
4. Observed Return-to-Duty Drug Test.
5. Enrollment in a Follow-Up Testing Program.

The Role of the SAP in the Return-to-Duty Process

A Substance Abuse Professional (SAP) plays a crucial role in evaluating, recommending treatment, and eventually clearing the employee to return to work.

SAP Responsibilities:

• Conduct an initial clinical evaluation
• Recommend education or treatment (therapy, workshops, rehab)
• Reassess the employee to determine readiness for duty

Completion of the SAP’s treatment program is mandatory before testing and returning to safety-sensitive duties.

Observed Return-to-Duty Drug Test

Before resuming work, the employee must pass a return-to-duty test:

• Direct Observation Required: A same-gender observer must witness the collection
• Negative Test Result Mandatory: No return to duty until the result is confirmed
• FMCSA Reporting: For DOT-regulated drivers, results are submitted to the FMCSA Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse

Follow-Up Testing Requirements

After passing the return-to-duty test, the employee enters a follow-up testing program that may last 12 to 60 months, depending on SAP recommendations.

Features:

• Random, unannounced testing
• All collections are observed
• Ongoing documentation to ensure continued compliance

Why Observed Collections Matter

Observed collections eliminate risks of sample tampering or cheating. It ensures:

• Authenticity of the specimen
• Compliance with DOT regulations
• Accuracy in employee assessment

How WSI Supports the Return-to-Duty Process

Workplace Screening Intelligence provides a streamlined solution for employers and drivers:

• SAP referral and coordination
• Scheduling of observed return-to-duty drug tests
• Full FMCSA Clearinghouse reporting
• Management of the follow-up testing schedule
• Ongoing support and compliance tracking

We ensure you have the correct male or female observer for each collection and handle all reporting responsibilities to help your employee or driver stay licensed and compliant.

Find a Nearby Drug Testing Location

WSI partners with over 20,000+ screening sites nationwide, offering:

• Convenient scheduling
• Fast turnaround times
• DOT and non-DOT compliant services

👉 Find a Location Near You

What If a Follow-Up Test Is Failed?

• Immediate removal from duties
• New SAP evaluation
• Possible termination based on company policy

More Than Just Testing: Full Compliance Services

In addition to return-to-duty management, WSI also offers:

• Drug & Alcohol Testing Policy Development
• Supervisor Reasonable Suspicion Training
• DER (Designated Employer Representative) Training
• Random Testing Programs (FMCSA, FAA, DOT)

Explore training options:
👉 Supervisor Training Info

Need Help Now?